Eleanor Duckworth would say in Bart’s new classroom children
are free to have wonderful ideas. The teacher accepts the risk associated
with providing Bart the opportunity to explore in chemistry. The classroom environment is one in which the
teacher provides “matter to think about” and students interact and explore to
construct meaning, but Bart lacks the knowledge (his "personal repetoire of thoughts, actions, predictions and feelings") needed. Airasian and Walsh would caution that
constructivist instruction should not constitute the only instructional process
and that pursuing constructivist methods of instruction does not mean accepting
anything and everything as evidence of learning.
Tuesday, June 26, 2012
Activity 3.3 Vygotsky’s Social Constructivism
Vygotsky emphasizes the importance of language in learning
and states that “learning and development are interrelated from the first day
of life”. Through obuchenie the zone of
proximal development (ZPD) is activated and awakens “developmental processes
that are able to operate only when the child is interacting with people in his
environment”. In the ZPD a child may
understand what a variable is, but not be able to articulate the process for
identifying variables in a word problem.
Through instruction and learning the child interacts with the teacher or
more capable peers to learn. Development
results from this learning. James
acknowledges the centrality of language in human learning when he says “verbal
material is the vehicle by which the mind thinks”. He describes language as increasingly
important in adolescence, when “”words, words, words” must constitute …an
always larger part …of what the human being has to learn”.
Activity 3.2 Cognitive Development
This video demonstrates a conservation problem that Piaget
explains in one of four stages of development, the Preoperational Thinking
stage that spans the age of 2 to 7. A
characteristic of this age, Piaget explains, is to think perceptively. This is described as intuitive thinking, and
in this instance the younger child perceives the taller, thinner glass as
holding more liquid. Children at this
age lack “some specific logical abilities” and thus cannot reason that the
amount of liquid has remained the same.
James describes a “native tendency to assimilate certain kinds of
conception at one age, and other kinds of conception at a later age”. In the first seven or eight years constructiveness
is the instinct most active in children; children accumulate knowledge when
they physically experience the world. In
adolescence they exhibit more abstract thought, and in late adolescence they ponder
abstract human relations.
Monday, June 25, 2012
Activity 3.1 Piaget’s Cognitive Constructivism
Learning occurs within individuals through an active process
of intrigue, investigation, reasoning and decision-making, and discovery. All humans are born without knowledge and
begin the process of building their own understanding of the world around them. Interest spurs individuals to investigation,
leading them to explore and experiment to answer self-generated questions. Considering the outcomes of their
investigation, individuals reason and make connections to previously
constructed knowledge, categorizing new information and sorting it into
knowledge constructions that associate and organize information in schemas that
are retrieved and considered when individuals encounter new information. All individuals are biologically motivated to
adapt to their environments and organize their knowledge in order to achieve
homeostasis. When individuals feel
unbalanced, out of the natural state of homeostasis, they are intrinsically
motivated to investigate, and thus begin the process of meaning-making
anew. Individuals learn in qualitatively
different ways and their paths of learning will be unique. Despite this, there
are biological constraints that govern individuals’ abilities to make decisions
about their discoveries; these are four distinct stages of learning. The educator as facilitator considers the
developmental stage of the students and provides as many opportunities for
discovery and exploration as possible.
I would assume that Piaget would not favor a system of
standards-based instruction and summative assessment. I wonder what he would suggest for
assessment. I also wonder what his
suggestions for college and career readiness would be. How would a prospective employer know that a
student was adequately prepared to carry out job duties or even exceed
expectations? What would a transition
from such an individualized learning style to the demands of the work place
feel like for the student? It seems that
some positions would accommodate this learning style readily, and others would
not. If there was a sweeping and
comprehensive movement of social constructivism, how would Piaget suggest the
workplace prepare for these students? Or
is the goal, despite individualized discovery learning, for students to emerge
from HS or college with roughly the same knowledge base?
Monday, June 18, 2012
Activity 2.5 Automaticity and Implicit Associations
I took the 2012 IAT, which asked about preferences for Barak O'Bama vs. Mitt Romney and preferences for either blacks or whites.
I was not surprised by the results of the IAT, but given my group's reactions I was surprised that I wasn't surprised.
Your data suggest a slight implicit preference for Barack Obama compared to Mitt Romney.
Your data suggest little to no difference in implicit preference between Black People and White People.
I think these results are particularly good for me, as I would not have wanted to discover a hidden prejudice. I would be sad to think that my subconcious preferences might influence my behavior toward people in my life in a negative way.
The question of what this has to do with both learning and associations is very complex and important for me with respect to this topic. Interestingly, I didn't specifically choose this topic, I just took what the site said it would like me to take. It turned out to be a very relevant survey.
I grew up in NE Ohio during the bussing era. I changed schools several times and was bussed all over the place. In my senior year in HS my school was closed three times as a result of race rioting. My father was a bigot and up until my years in HS I was too. At some point I began to form my own opinion and over time my life changed dramatically. I now have four wonderful, biracial children and a wonderful african american husband. So, I wonder now if the question of reflection is again the source of deviation from the expected or anticipated behavior that one may have expected in my case. I certainly was taught to associate African Americans with crime, violence, theivery, and many other negative characteristics. In terms of Jame's point of the power of associations, I had powerful associations that definitely shaped my attitudes and behavior for a good part of my youth. Even when my concious thoughts and perceptions began to change, I would still be more frightened when passing a black man on the street then when passing a white man on the street. So, how did those powerful associations shape my future behavior as a child, and when did they begin to lose their power over my future behavior as an adult?
James says in his discussion of what native reactions are that "Each of us is in fact what he is almost exclusively by virtue of his imitativeness." and also "Emulation is the impulse to imitate what you see another doing, in order not to appear inferior; and it is hard to draw a sharp line betwen the manifestations of the two impulses, so inextricably do they mix their effects." This would seem to offer a very strong reason for my childhood behavior. James goes on to say "the proper pedagogic moment to work skill in, and to clench the useful habit, is when the native impulse is most acutely present." and he refers to the ripening of our impulsive tendencies and the law of transitoriness. So, is it a question of this particular training in my life coming after the perfect moment (at least from my father's perspective) had already come and gone? Or is it a question of native tendencies, and the fact that there maybe was no native tendency to which this teaching could be attached? Or is it the fact that in this case there really would be no "useful actions" to make automatic and habitual. OR, does this all come back to the question of what it means to be educated? James also says, at the end of chapter VIII when he discusses good and bad, "Silently, between all the details of his business, the power of judging in all that class of matter will have builte itself up withing him as a possession that will never pass away." Perhaps this is the effect of knowledge and differential reinforcement. Perhaps there were stronger reinforcers attached to other associations and behaviors.
I was not surprised by the results of the IAT, but given my group's reactions I was surprised that I wasn't surprised.
Your data suggest a slight implicit preference for Barack Obama compared to Mitt Romney.
Your data suggest little to no difference in implicit preference between Black People and White People.
I think these results are particularly good for me, as I would not have wanted to discover a hidden prejudice. I would be sad to think that my subconcious preferences might influence my behavior toward people in my life in a negative way.
The question of what this has to do with both learning and associations is very complex and important for me with respect to this topic. Interestingly, I didn't specifically choose this topic, I just took what the site said it would like me to take. It turned out to be a very relevant survey.
I grew up in NE Ohio during the bussing era. I changed schools several times and was bussed all over the place. In my senior year in HS my school was closed three times as a result of race rioting. My father was a bigot and up until my years in HS I was too. At some point I began to form my own opinion and over time my life changed dramatically. I now have four wonderful, biracial children and a wonderful african american husband. So, I wonder now if the question of reflection is again the source of deviation from the expected or anticipated behavior that one may have expected in my case. I certainly was taught to associate African Americans with crime, violence, theivery, and many other negative characteristics. In terms of Jame's point of the power of associations, I had powerful associations that definitely shaped my attitudes and behavior for a good part of my youth. Even when my concious thoughts and perceptions began to change, I would still be more frightened when passing a black man on the street then when passing a white man on the street. So, how did those powerful associations shape my future behavior as a child, and when did they begin to lose their power over my future behavior as an adult?
James says in his discussion of what native reactions are that "Each of us is in fact what he is almost exclusively by virtue of his imitativeness." and also "Emulation is the impulse to imitate what you see another doing, in order not to appear inferior; and it is hard to draw a sharp line betwen the manifestations of the two impulses, so inextricably do they mix their effects." This would seem to offer a very strong reason for my childhood behavior. James goes on to say "the proper pedagogic moment to work skill in, and to clench the useful habit, is when the native impulse is most acutely present." and he refers to the ripening of our impulsive tendencies and the law of transitoriness. So, is it a question of this particular training in my life coming after the perfect moment (at least from my father's perspective) had already come and gone? Or is it a question of native tendencies, and the fact that there maybe was no native tendency to which this teaching could be attached? Or is it the fact that in this case there really would be no "useful actions" to make automatic and habitual. OR, does this all come back to the question of what it means to be educated? James also says, at the end of chapter VIII when he discusses good and bad, "Silently, between all the details of his business, the power of judging in all that class of matter will have builte itself up withing him as a possession that will never pass away." Perhaps this is the effect of knowledge and differential reinforcement. Perhaps there were stronger reinforcers attached to other associations and behaviors.
I found this video very interesting because it not only is an example of shaping behavior in a goldfish (if there was ever any doubt that that behavior can be shaped I have only to think of the fish I have had) but also because the video includes an example of discrimination. Discrimination, in my mind, is one step closer to being reflective, which is a human trait that I consider differentiating. That is, I feel that humans' ability to be reflective is the reason we are able to demonstrate behaviors that are not expected and predictable. So, although discrimination may be more complex than a simple conditioned response, clearly it is not the only component or defining factor in reflection. Do you think a goldfish is capable of drawing conclusions? (i.e. "The light is not on so I know I won't get any food.")
Activity 2.3 Corrected Post
Three Main
Points:
·
Cognitive
psychology does not directly address the real problem in American education,
which is inefficiency in teaching.
·
Educators
must be schooled in effective teaching methodology, which includes the
consistent use of reinforcement.
·
Individualized,
programmed instruction which offers many opportunities for success, clearly
states objectives and effectively schedules reinforcement will lead to a much
higher rate of learning in the same number of school hours.
Skinner would still be ashamed of American
education. Instructional programming has
not kept pace with growth and innovation in technology. Instruction is infrequently differentiated
and individualized and large scale standardized tests perpetuate uniformity across
classrooms and schools within a state. Instructional
programming is not designed to provide “abundant reinforcement” (Skinner, 1984),
but rather uniform performance.
B. F.
Skinner would be very pleased with the school of one concept. It uses an algorithm to implement successful
teaching strategies and frees up the teachers.
Programmed learning gives each student what they need to be successful
through individual technology-based instruction, and does not require that
students advance at the same pace as their classmates. Instruction is determined by student needs. The
responsibility for effective teaching in the School of One Model rests with the
teacher.
Activity 2.3 Videos on Behaviorism
I believe that
Skinner would still be ashamed of
American education for several reasons. Instructional
programming has not kept pace with growth and innovation in technology. Effective instructional design is a young
field with possibilities such as distance learning relatively unexplored and under-researched. Instruction is infrequently differentiated
and individualized and large scale standardized tests perpetuate uniformity across
classrooms and schools within a state. All
students are expected to learn the same things at the same time and demonstrate
their knowledge in the same way. Instructional
programming is not designed to provide “abundant reinforcement” (Skinner, 1984),
but rather uniform performance.
B. F.
Skinner would be very pleased with the school of one concept. It uses an algorithm to implement successful
teaching strategies and frees up the teachers.
School of one uses programmed learning to give each student what they
need to be successful through individual technology-based instruction, and does
not require that students follow a prescribed course; advancing at the same
pace as their classmates. The responsibility
for effective teaching in the School of One Model (enabled by New York schools
or other contributing organizations or bodies) rests with the teacher. These are all solutions Skinner offered in
his 1984 article
Activity 2.2 Behaviorism as a Theory of Learning
Behaviorism assumes that man is born a blank slate and that all behavior is a response to a specified antecedent condition. Thus man is not autonomous, but rather his behavior can be anticipated and predicted through careful observation of the conditions in his environment. Reinforcement strengthens behavior and thus, through the use of differential reinforcement, human behavior can be shaped and with successive approximations learning can be directed toward a desired outcome.
Sunday, June 17, 2012
Activity 2.1 A Philosophical Question
<a href="http://www.chartgo.com/linkshare.do?id=4c6ec08daa"> <img src="http://www.chartgo.com/link.do?id=4c6ec08daa" title="ChartGo.com" alt="Online Graphing" border="0" /></a><br /> <a href="http://www.ChartGo.com" >Make a graph</a>
Saturday, June 16, 2012
Tuesday, June 12, 2012
Activity 1.5 William James' Talks to Teachers, Preface through Chapter IV
The Preface
In his talks to teachers William James hopes to inspire
teachers to think of their students as their students think of themselves. He hopes to offer them insightful and
practical methods for assessing a student’s mental life and using that to teach
effectively.
Connection: I
believe that frequently when I have an instructional goal I begin to think of
task analyzing, or breaking down the goal, to try to present the instruction in
a way that seems logical to me. Although
I try to think of the way the content might make sense to a student, I am not
always sure that I take a student’s perspective. I am not sure that I always learn enough, or
understand well enough, who the learners are.
Psychology and the
Teaching Art
Psychology and teaching are two distinctly different lenses
for observing and working with students and the art of teaching does not grow
out of the field of psychology. The
teacher’s work is much more concrete and practical than that of the
psychologist and involves a practice that that evolves as the teacher learns to
engage the student and engender interest in the content being delivered.
Connection: I
think in my experience with training and instruction those who are delivering
instruction are often attributing psychological underpinnings to lack of
progress in instruction. Perhaps some
individuals feel they do not understand the psychology of teaching to the
degree that they should, but I more often find that as trainers we assume we
know more about how the minds of our students work than we do. This is a reminder to me to consider my
instruction as the root determinant of engagement.
The Stream of Consciousness
Within each of us, in all our waking moments, there occurs a
constant series of sensations and thought that are associated via our own
unique experiences. It is not reasonable
to chop up or delineate instruction into separate units that are seen as
independent of each other because all that we experience is affected by our steady
stream of concrete focal points and marginal thoughts that exist in each
dynamic stream of consciousness, unique to the individual.
Connection: In
thinking about teaching I must recognize and accept the fact that the minds of
the students will each be engaged in their own stream of consciousness. Although initially this may seem like a
frustrating lack of attention, it is actually just a state of being. Thus, in delivering instruction I must
endeavor to provide channels or possible directions of exploration that might
lend themselves to an improved understanding of the topic. I must also accept that each student brings
their own building blocks to the construction of meaning.
The Child as a Behaving Organism
The stream of consciousness may be
determined to serve two functions: to
lead to action and to lead to knowledge.
Most of what we perceive to be abstract thought is actually tied to our
behavior which in turn is determined in large part by our adaptation to our
environment; behavior has a pragmatic base.
Connection: When I am teaching I must consider how
learning does not occur independent of the environment in which we learn, or
the environment in which the students experience their lives. I might think about trying to integrate
naturally occurring behaviors or adaptations in the instruction. I might also think of ways to encourage
students to share the connections they are making to our learning. Also, I should keep in mind that behaviors we
engage in, in our classrooms, will lead to learning, and further encourage
students to share the learning that occurs through our activities.
Education and Behavior
Education is the organization of
behaviors of an individual that comprise a series of acquired habits that the
learner has acquired through external impressions and factors in their environment. Teachers must be aware that all that they do
makes an impression on a student and will therefore lead to the acquisition of
a habit that will be incorporated in their behavioral schema.
Connection: This
makes me think of parenting and the fact that when you are in an environment
with learners they are constantly observing.
As parents, I think that we might be more mindful of this. I see behaviors in my children that I feel
have been engendered by the impressions I have made on them. This is very powerful. I have an opportunity to teach when the
learner does not realize that I am teaching and I should always monitor the
response to my behaviors and change my behaviors when I feel like they are
making the wrong impression.
Activity 1.4 What does it mean to be educated?
To be educated is to be exposed to a plethora of
perspectives, or lenses, for seeing and thinking about the world and life
experiences. It is often focused, but it
always involves a problem-solving and thoughtful, reflective process. Being educated implies recognition of complexity
and a willingness to consider all sources of information and typically a broad
based superficial understanding of varied topics. Being educated means you have identified
yourself at some point as a learner.
Activity 1.3 Metaphor for Learning
Learning is like a hike in the Cascade Mountains; it’s a
great adventure. The landscape is
diverse and there are many paths to take.
One begins the journey with an expectation of what will be learned, but
along the way you happen upon many unexpected pleasures and struggles. Occasionally you must rethink your choices
and maybe even double back to take a different path. At other times you round a corner and there
is an unexpected panoramic vista that is breathtaking; and you suddenly know just
where you are, and just where you’ve been.
In some instances an effective guide accompanies you on your journey and
shares with you the wisdom they have garnered on their personal journey, information about the landscape and
directions for navigation. In others,
you must go it alone and discern what works best for you. There is often a goal for your learning, the
pinnacle at the top that you strive to obtain.
When you finally arrive at your destination you have a chain of
memories, a sense of accomplishment, and you know that you have achieved a
worthwhile goal that will be yours forever. You are satisfied and confident
that you are where you want to be. You
pause and reflect whilst you sit and eat and drink. You stand on the peak, look around, and
realize that there are so many mountains yet to be climbed, so many things yet
to be learned. Your body nourished, you
rise for the next journey.
Monday, June 11, 2012
Activity 1.2 Monty
1. How should the owners respond?
- call an emergency verterninary hospital/call line or the veterinarian who examined Monty and prescribed his medicine to make sure he doesn't need to seek emergency services
- ask if the behavior Monty is exhibiting can be attributed to a progression of his condition or heart disease
- ask if Monty's behavior could be a side effect of the medication (tell the emergency contact the medication Monty is taking and the dosage and directions of dosing)
- return Monty to the verterniary hospital or office for a follow up examination
- bring samples of the vegetation in the yard and any other item that Monty may have eaten to the veterinarian
- describe Monty's previous behavior to the veterinarian to ascertain if the changes in his behavior and health are identified with any particular condition or support the suspected cause of heart disease
- create a safe place for Monty to rest, attempt to structure it in such a way that he is able to stay somewhat upright or is supported by pillows or other supports on his sides
- cover Monty's space/place with towels or blankets that can be easily removed and cleaned
- ask all the family members if they have seen Monty eating anything or if they have noticed anything happening to Monty that was unusual
- take samples of Monty's stool and vomit to the vet for analysis
- make sure Monty doesn't come into contact with any other pets at home
- make sure there's no possibility that Monty has something contagious that can be transmitted to or infect humans
- keep a journal over the three days of all observations of Monty (what he eats, when he sleeps, coughing, sneezing, behavior, etc.)
- try to determine what makes Monty comfortable and provide that for him (food, water, attention from adults)
- caution the children to stay clear of Monty until he feels better (no touching)
- reward Monty for good behavior
- clean the carpet
Activity 1.2 Why Johnny Can't Learn
1. What should Johnny's parents do?
2. What should Miss Jones do?
3. What is a likely explanation for Johnny's new problems?
I honestly don't know that I have any idea what is the most likely explanation. I think that because of his apparent withdrawal from his peer group and defensive behaviors I would suspect bullying. Johnny is in a new school and middle school is a big change from elementary. Johnny has moved so frequently that it is unlikely that he has formed many strong and enduring friendships that can support him in this latest transition. However, when school begins Johnny is friendly, responsive and apparently enthusiastic about school. This would lead me to believe that there is some situation or an event that has precipitated Johnny's change in behavior. So, I might suspect that Johnny was not being accepted by his peer group, that he was not being welcomed or included by his peers, and that he might even be the target of bullying. He is small and new to the school (a likely target for bullies) and is involved in many fights. If Johnny is being bullied, parents or teachers might be able to find evidence of this in computer records or interviews of Johnny's peers. If none of the information gathering caused anyone to believe that Johnny was being bullied then other causes of behavior changes, such as drug use or peer pressure should be considered. It's possible that Johnny's transition has been more difficult than those of previous moves and that he is angry and resentful because he has had to make another move. It's also possible that there is a phsyiological reason for his behavior. It could be that Johnny is being pressured by peers or a particular peer group to display confrontational and oppositional behavior.
- talk to Johnny
- review the school curriculum and expectations and compare them to those of Johnny's previous school(s)
- talk to Johnny's friends (anyone they can identify who had a friendly relationship with Johnny before his behavior changed and anyone who they can identify who spends time with Johnny that they have access to, such as neighbor's children, bus drivers, etc.; all of the above if given parent permission)
- take Johnny to see a physician (and based on their own research and the response of Johnny's general practitioner to specialists such as allergists, neurophysiologists, etc.)
- research counselors who specialize in adolescent behavior and talk with Johnny about visiting a counselor, consider the availability of an "art therapist"
- provide Johnny with whatever art supplies they can afford at home and give him a safe and private place in the home
- ask Johnny to respond to their questions through his art, and interpret his response for them
- take Johnny to see a counselor
- talk with Johnny's teachers and school administrators (be sure to include, of course, the art teacher)
- test Johnny for drugs
- try to identify the point at which Johnny's behavior changed and begin a dialogue with Johnny about one incident at a time
- ask Johnny why he is different in art, and what art means to him
- search Johnny's room, personal belongings, and any and all computer records that are related to Johnny and/or any of his activities
- respond positively or reward steps that Johnny takes to change his behavior to what is accepted in a specific environment or to communicate what he is thinking or feeling
- determine to the best of their ability to determine if Johnny is doing anything, or involved with anyone, that they don't know about
2. What should Miss Jones do?
- try to talk with Johnny
- tell her administrator/principal what she has observed
- re-review Johnny's records and files
- consult the school guidance counselor and/or school psychologist
- talk with all of Johnny's teachers, with special attention or requests for many details from Johnny's art teacher
- see if there is a trained observer or diagnostician available to observe Johnny or talk with Johnny or both
- maintain very regular contact with Johnny's parents
- review Johnny's schoolwork and computer records
- talk to the teachers, counselors and administrators at Johnny's previous schools
- try to identify any peer that shares activities or interests with Johnny (i.e. an interest in art) and make interaction with that peer(s) possible
- discuss alternative ways in which Johnny can satisfy his class requirements temporarily so losing homework and books is not such a problem
- make after-school study and work time available to Johnny in a setting that may reduce his group anxiety
- request that Johnny's parents meet with a school team to come up with a plan of action
- request that Johnny's parents share any information they obtain outside of school with the team
- possibly write a behavior plan for school and school environments
- explore opportunities for Johnny to spend time doing what he enjoys (art clubs, etc.) and attempt to encourage or support relationships that revolve around these activities
- request that Johnny's parents share any relevant medical information or family medical information or history
3. What is a likely explanation for Johnny's new problems?
I honestly don't know that I have any idea what is the most likely explanation. I think that because of his apparent withdrawal from his peer group and defensive behaviors I would suspect bullying. Johnny is in a new school and middle school is a big change from elementary. Johnny has moved so frequently that it is unlikely that he has formed many strong and enduring friendships that can support him in this latest transition. However, when school begins Johnny is friendly, responsive and apparently enthusiastic about school. This would lead me to believe that there is some situation or an event that has precipitated Johnny's change in behavior. So, I might suspect that Johnny was not being accepted by his peer group, that he was not being welcomed or included by his peers, and that he might even be the target of bullying. He is small and new to the school (a likely target for bullies) and is involved in many fights. If Johnny is being bullied, parents or teachers might be able to find evidence of this in computer records or interviews of Johnny's peers. If none of the information gathering caused anyone to believe that Johnny was being bullied then other causes of behavior changes, such as drug use or peer pressure should be considered. It's possible that Johnny's transition has been more difficult than those of previous moves and that he is angry and resentful because he has had to make another move. It's also possible that there is a phsyiological reason for his behavior. It could be that Johnny is being pressured by peers or a particular peer group to display confrontational and oppositional behavior.
Sunday, June 10, 2012
Activity 1.1
Hi. My name is Karen. I live in Lexington, KY right now with my husband and four children. I am originally from Northeast Ohio, but I spent 23 years living on the west coast before I moved to Lexington. I am in the Instructional Systems Design program at UK. I love to learn, and I love school, so I have a fairly broad background educationally. I also love to swim, hike, and bike when I can make the time. I have three sons and a daughter. They keep me very busy, and are my true passion. I enjoy being part of their activities and they are so much fun!! I hope that I can continue learning and expanding my horizons and watch my children do the same. Maybe when I grow up I will have learned to manage the ups and downs of lfe with grace and humor and empathy.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)